Disable Preloader

CaseLaw

Longe Vs. BN Plc (2010) CLR 3(a) (SC)

Judgement delivered on March 5th 2010

Brief

  • Parties to a suit
  • Brief
  • Reply brief
  • Executive & Non executive Director
  • Removal of a director
  • Contract of employment
  • Suspension
  • Court must not make case for parties
  • S.266 CAMA

Facts

The Appellant was the Plaintiff before the Federal High Court Lagos where on 4-07-02, he issued a Writ of Summons against the Respondent as the Defendant claiming the following reliefs:

  • "i.
    A declaration that the Defendant's Board of Directors cannot lawfully hold any meeting of the said Board without giving notice thereof to the Plaintiff and accordingly all decisions taken at any such meeting is unlawful, invalid, null and void and incapable of having any legal consequence;
  • ii.
    A declaration that in particular the decision of the Defendant's Board of Directors held on the 13th of June 2002 to revoke the Plaintiff's appointment as Managing Director/Chief Executive is wrongful, unlawful, invalid, null and void and incapable of having any legal consequence;
  • iii.
    A declaration that any purported implementation of the said decision made by the Board on the 13th of June 2002 (including any appointment to the office held by the Plaintiff in the Defendant Company) is ineffective, unlawful, null and void;
  • iv.
    (An order of injunction restraining the said Defendants from giving effect or continuing to give effect to any of the decisions of the Board mentioned in claims (i) and (ii) hereof without first complying with the mandatory procedural requirements stipulated in Section 266(3) of C.A.M.A.;
  • v.
    A declaration that the Plaintiff is entitled to remain in the premises allocated to him by the Defendant including the enjoyment of all associated services until the expiration of a reasonable time from the date of any lawful and valid termination of his contract of service with the Defendant;
  • vi.
    In the alternative to the foregoing, the Plaintiff claims the sum of N136,614,584.00 being the amount due and owing to the Plaintiff as at 13th June 2002;
  • <vii.
    Interest on the said sum of N136,614,584.00 at the rate of 21% per annum or at such other rate of interest as the Court may adjudge to be fair and just.
  • viii.
    In further alternative to claims (i) to (iii) the Plaintiff also claims the sum of N804,685,117.00, US$207,360.00 and Stg £359,100.00 being special damages suffered by him as a result of the wrongful termination of appointment."

The parties later filed and exchanged pleadings after which the suit was tried by Nwodo J. (as she then was). On 9-10-03, in the judgment, the Appellant's claims I to V were dismissed whilst claims VI to VIII which were withdrawn by Plaintiff's Counsel were struck out. Dissatisfied with the judgment the Plaintiff brought an appeal before the Court of Appeal, Lagos. The Court of Appeal in its judgment on 5-1-06 dismissed Plaintiff's appeal. Still dissatisfied the Plaintiff appealed to the Supreme Court.

Issues

  • 1.
    Whether it is proper in law for the Court of Appeal to have jettisoned suo motu in...
    Read More